Marple Website Community Calendar

Archive => Archived Boards => Sale of Hibbert Lane Campus to Supermarket Chain => Topic started by: Duke Fame on July 31, 2011, 12:17:16 PM

Title: Stratgies to oppose a Supermarket
Post by: Duke Fame on July 31, 2011, 12:17:16 PM
The laminated posters do raise awareness of the issues but we do need some realistic strategies to encourage the bidding supermarkets to drop any roposals of a big store.
Title: Re: Stratgies to oppose a Supermarket
Post by: Duke Fame on July 31, 2011, 12:20:51 PM
Starter for 10:
How about on say the 2nd week of September there is a boycott of the two supermarkets. All Marple residents to shop either locally or at Morissons and even picket Dan Bank to force any online deliveries to turn back.

This would need a lot of leafletting, local TV/radio and press. Twittering etc.
Title: Re: Stratgies to oppose a Supermarket
Post by: Maria on July 31, 2011, 12:27:38 PM
Sounds good, I agree that posters raise awareness only but do little else. 

With you on boycotting/picketing etc and I am sure others will be too.  Feel we need a further meeting to discuss this further and also feel we should have designated people to write letters to the local councillors en masse.  I have contacts with the MEN so can get in touch to see if they will run a story in the Stockport Express etc further to the previous report.

Title: Re: Stratgies to oppose a Supermarket
Post by: Maria on July 31, 2011, 12:32:46 PM
Actually on reflection online deliveries can help with the argument against a store.

People have the choice in the village but can also order online if they need to so counters the Co-op monopoly argument.  We need to ensure we don't become anti-Tesco and keep it all about preserving the village community rather than just being against Tesco as a whole and against progress etc.

I'll get involved in whatever the Marple in Action group decide to help but I am conscious it must be structured and reasoned.
Title: Re: Stratgies to oppose a Supermarket
Post by: JMC on July 31, 2011, 01:36:46 PM
Actually on reflection online deliveries can help with the argument against a store.

People have the choice in the village but can also order online if they need to so counters the Co-op monopoly argument.  We need to ensure we don't become anti-Tesco and keep it all about preserving the village community rather than just being against Tesco as a whole and against progress etc.

I'll get involved in whatever the Marple in Action group decide to help but I am conscious it must be structured and reasoned.

Excellent points. Any campaign needs to address all the points FOR a big supermarket (any supermarket) and be able to counter them all. Eg. More jobs, cheaper prices, investment, money for college, more competition etc. As that is probably what they will come out with to make a case for their store.
Title: Re: Stratgies to oppose a Supermarket
Post by: Smithy166 on July 31, 2011, 03:01:14 PM
This idea me be slighty bazzare, but hey (pardon the refrence here) "every little helps"
If we could somehow aquire a small chunk of land, either next to the college site, or at the proposed "mega-bout" then we could refuse to sell said chunk of land to the concil, forcing them to move there plan elsewere. Or atleast i think thats how it works ::)
Title: Re: Stratgies to oppose a Supermarket
Post by: Duke Fame on August 01, 2011, 09:49:43 AM

Excellent points. Any campaign needs to address all the points FOR a big supermarket (any supermarket) and be able to counter them all. Eg. More jobs, cheaper prices, investment, money for college, more competition etc. As that is probably what they will come out with to make a case for their store.

Quite right. Any store will ahve been through this before with planty of arguments along the lines presented on the 'TESCO' thread. We need to anticipate the arguments in favour and counter them.

Job creation? I think that's not relevent as losing say the Fruit & Veg shop will lose staff, owners will lose an income, the landlord of the shop loses income for which is not spent into the economy. Further along the supply line, the local suppliers will lose a revenue stream, lay off staff etc. Multiply that to the bread shops, the co-op etc and the job inpact will be neutral at best.
Title: Re: Stratgies to oppose a Supermarket
Post by: Smithy166 on August 02, 2011, 08:06:10 PM
Not sure weither this is worth anything, but hey ho i'll suggest it anyway.

Is there any chance we could get a huge banner printed with "marple in action" and the web address on it? If we could then the banner could be strung accross dan bank, so that people can see it. However, the people putting up the banner would have to make sure that its hgih enough to allow artics/busses underneath.
Title: Re: Stratgies to oppose a Supermarket
Post by: Taurus on August 02, 2011, 08:17:23 PM
Not sure weither this is worth anything, but hey ho i'll suggest it anyway.

Is there any chance we could get a huge banner printed with "marple in action" and the web address on it? If we could then the banner could be strung accross dan bank, so that people can see it. However, the people putting up the banner would have to make sure that its hgih enough to allow artics/busses underneath.

Good idea but alas not enough trees since Jason Voorhees visited with his chain saw
Title: Re: Stratgies to oppose a Supermarket
Post by: Duke Fame on August 02, 2011, 09:40:49 PM
Good idea but alas not enough trees since Jason Voorhees visited with his chain saw

Very good  :D



Nice idea although it would have to be very high. I  reckon the council would have it down in a jiffy which in itself could create a bit of media coverage.
Title: Re: Stratgies to oppose a Supermarket
Post by: Lisa Oldham on August 03, 2011, 09:38:10 AM
council cant take it down if its on private property!!  Sure the bloke who owns it would be up for it
Title: Re: Stratgies to oppose a Supermarket
Post by: Smithy166 on August 03, 2011, 10:13:21 AM
Also, how about a march?
We could start in the park, then march in a huge group through market street, past hibbert lane campus (slowing down ofcourse) then turn right onto buxton lane and march past the buxton lane campus (again, slowing down.) then contiune on to that small parking area at the beginning of the middlewood way. Almost like you seen unions marching though the streets about job cuts.
Title: Re: Stratgies to oppose a Supermarket
Post by: Harry on August 03, 2011, 10:13:48 AM
If anybody put a banner across Dan Bank they would have to be prepared to face the consequences if it came down, and possibly covered a vehicle's windscreen as groups of young people were headed to/from school. It doesn't take much imagination to envisage the horrors that this could cause.
Title: Re: Stratgies to oppose a Supermarket
Post by: Smithy166 on August 03, 2011, 10:25:54 AM
If anybody put a banner across Dan Bank they would have to be prepared to face the consequences if it came down, and possibly covered a vehicle's windscreen as groups of young people were headed to/from school. It doesn't take much imagination to envisage the horrors that this could cause.
That is why you'd make sure that is was tightly secured.
Title: Re: Stratgies to oppose a Supermarket
Post by: amazon on August 03, 2011, 11:08:38 AM
Also, how about a march?
We could start in the park, then march in a huge group through market street, past hibbert lane campus (slowing down ofcourse) then turn right onto buxton lane and march past the buxton lane campus (again, slowing down.) then contiune on to that small parking area at the beginning of the middlewood way. Almost like you seen unions marching though the streets about job cuts.

              like onward Christian soldiers .
Title: Re: Stratgies to oppose a Supermarket
Post by: squirrel123 on August 03, 2011, 12:42:29 PM
Good idea about a banner.....and the kids are off school at the moment so it wouldnt affect school traffic for a few weeks at least.
Title: Re: Stratgies to oppose a Supermarket
Post by: Miss Marple on August 03, 2011, 01:36:54 PM
Hi we have already got a few things planned and are just waiting to get organised  would anyone like to become involved .  if you do please contact with your email address or telephone number.  MARPLE IN ACTION is not just a few people it's the whole community and we need your help  ???